Fired after reading patient records
Hi Ronnie Ann. I got myself into a predicament and need your advice. Until yesterday, I worked in the office at a healthcare facility. But I got fired for reading patient records. Here’s the thing … I was given access to both the office manager’s and the administrator’s passwords as part of my job. And we were actually recommended to read patient charts to keep abreast of things.
I only work part time and on my days off I would read patient records, which is accessible online (kind of a dumb setup if you ask me). Anyway, I didn’t know that reading patient records is a serious offense. And so I was fired for doing that.
“How do I answer the job interview question why was I fired from my previous job?”
I hate that I’m going to have this stigma attached to me. But I honestly had no clue that this was against the health regulations. (And we were encouraged to read records.)
I had no previous training in the medical field. Also some of my current training went by the wayside because I was only part time. And they initially hired me to work the weekend.
You were a great help to me last time I asked for help. And so I hope you can help me again. I’m sorry to bother you once more. But I would be extremely grateful for any advice would be extremely grateful. I can’t seem to find any help online.
~ JoJo
HIPAA, reading patient records, & hope
Hi JoJo!
I’m so sorry you’re going through this. While I wish I could make this all go away for you, there are a few things I’d like to explain first. But most of all … hang in there. At one point or another, we all do things we wish we could take back. You’ll be ok.
First, this is a lesson you will remember a long time. And that’s a useful thing in case you ever work in a hospital or health facility again. (I’ll explain in a second.) But please don’t worry. As you create new work experience to offer in its place, the stigma will eventually fade into the distant past.
HIPAA law as it relates to patient records
There is a Federal law called HIPAA that, among other things, protects the privacy of our health records. And that includes reading patient records. Most major computer systems are available online now, JoJo. But the protection is that you need a secure password to get in.
Quite honestly, if the nursing home were operating from a security-first standpoint, you should have been given limited access. And NOT passwords assigned to others. That’s a mistake on them. They know reading patient records for entertainment or other non-medical needs is a big no-no!
These records are private. And no one except people directly concerned with treatment should be reading them. Personally, I would be appalled if I thought just anyone was reading my health records in their spare time! (I just want you to really understand what happened here.)
No question this company didn’t handle security as well as they could have. But considering the position you held there, reading private personal patient records while off duty is simply not ok. If you really get that and learn from it, I think this is a lesson that will serve you well for the rest of your career.
So where do you go from here?
All that said … I don’t want you to beat yourself up for reading patient records. Or feel bad. You really didn’t know. And we all make mistakes. Especially ones we weren’t properly advised about, as in your case. And we all move on. Lord knows I’ve screwed up so many times I can’t count it on my fingers!
Maybe someone else wants to chime in here. But for me the best way to handle this is by really knowing in your heart you’re a good employee. And that you will do your best for your next employer. Maybe even try harder as a result of lessons learned.
Some interview logic (and mindset) to help
In the interview, all I would say when asked is something like “I made a mistake. And I learned from it.” If you like, you can add that you know mistakes occasionally happen. But you believe that the best thing we can do is learn from them. And then work extra hard never to let it happen again!
And hopefully you seal the deal by sincerely looking them in the eyes as you tell them you intend to work double hard to shine in this job. Maybe even give them another example from a job or elsewhere where you turned a mistake into something really good.
Real-life work stories help,
Especially if they end on a positive note.
And by being honest — again, without going into details — that may also help when they do reference checking. A good employer will like that you didn’t lie. But your approach, leaving them with s strong and positive impression, is really your strongest interview tool.
A few more thoughts
I have every faith you’ll be OK, JoJo. Don’t hold anger or resentment about all this. Least of all toward yourself. That can show in interviews and when networking.
Brush yourself off. And go find that next job. Each mistake makes us stronger. Just show the most positive, pleasant, fully-engaged side of yourself when you interview and you’ll get another chance.
Good luck!
About the author…
Ronnie Ann, founder of Work To The Wise and Work Coach Cafe, bases her real-world advice on her many years as an organizational consultant where she helped interview and hire people, added to a certificate from NYU in Career Planning & Development and her own adventures as a serial job seeker.
More posts to help
What Are Transferable Skills?
15 Job Search Tips To Help You Get a Job
So Many Mistakes! How Do I Start My Career Over?
How To Mentally Prepare for a Job Interview
18 Practical Tips to Help You Ace Your Job Interview
15 Things I Look for When I Interview People
So What Really Happens After a Job Interview?
10 Reasons You Didn’t Get the Job Offer
Should You Send a Post-Interview Thank You? [Sample]
How Do I Interview After Being Fired?
They Want Supervisor References. Are These OK?
10 Things I Look for When I Screen Resumes & Cover Letters
Ronnie Ann says
You said: “It’s never too late!” Yup. 🙂
As for feeling like you need to reveal details, maybe if you don’t leave it open ended it will help. Show what you’ve learned from it and bring it back to the job you’re interviewing for – showing how you will handle things differently or better or how what you learned only made you more determined, etc.
Other than that, it’s just about looking them in the eyes and sticking to your guns not to tell all. No interviewer needs to know every detail. Tell them enough, use the technique above and move on. If they still keep pressing, just say you hope they understand that you respect the privacy of the other company as you will also respect theirs. And again look them in the eyes, smile, and stop. 😉
Good luck!
StevieGirl says
How can one be “honest” without revealing details. Whenever I have tried to do this (generalize), I seem to get drilled and feel pressured to reveal details. This might have more to do with my own insecurities, but I’m also one that cannot lie or even “fudge” the truth. I so wish that I would have taken a debate class in high school or college. I know: It’s never too late! I am desperately seeking employment and have transportation and financial issues. In other words, I have no wiggle room!
Thank you in advance ~ StevieGirl
Ronnie Ann says
Thanks for sharing this with us, Kathy. I’m so sorry this happened to you. I don’t know anyone who hasn’t screwed up intentionally or unintentionally, so I just want to give you a big hug and wish you the best of luck!
If you are asked what happened in a job interview, it’s best to be honest that you made a mistake (no details needed) and learned from this experience, have never had a problem before, and emphasize the strengths you bring to this new job. Be sure of yourself and it will show.
Good luck!
Kathy says
I had about the same thing happen to me and I have a hard time forgiving myself or knowing what to say in an interview. We had our passwords flying around for our timesheet. Well, I happened to look at my co-workers timesheet. I immediately confessed to both the co-worker and my boss. They told me everything was fine and thanked me for my honesty. Three weeks later, out of the blue, I was called in and asked to resign and sign a form to relieve the DDS of any potenial problems. Then was told to collect my belongings. I did not sign my rights away and did not get my severance and had to ask for my vacation for he was holding that, too.
So, what can I say? It was a mistake. Timesheets are not private or part of any personnel file. I was totally honest and remorseful…..K